What did GD mean by the difference between Big Bang, EXO, and SHINee?


Article: SHINee and EXO can't compose their own songs?... GD's clueless statement

Source:
Mydaily via Nate

1. [+655, -94] I am aware that there are members in EXO and SHINee who can write their own songs... but that's it, I only know that they have members that can. I don't know which specific songs they wrote, and I think only their fans would know that. What GD meant in his interview was not that EXO and SHINee don't know how to compose songs but that Big Bang is more known for that aspect than the other groups are.

2. [+489, -65] Anyone can write and compose songs. The issue is whether or not it appeals to the public...

3. [+423, -49] From someone in a neutral perspective/not a fan of EXO/SHINee/Big Bang... I just know that the other two groups aren't as responsible for composing as many songs as Big Bang are... it's only their fans who know.

4. [+63, -10] Don't know why people are taking it so seriously... GD clearly didn't mean ill by his statement. Sure Jonghyun may have written a lot of his songs but he's just now starting compared to GD who is well known for his composing... and this is my first time hearing that EXO writes their own songs as well. Good work to everyone ㅎㅎ

5. [+57, -19] You can't really compare someone who composes an entire album to someone who includes one or two self compositions per album. Was this article written by an SM fan? Sure EXO can throw in a song or two they wrote but you can't honestly consider them being self-composers ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ I get that GD is not that well liked but he didn't say anything wrong. He merely stated the differences between the groups.

6. [+53, -27] I rarely listen to idol music but SHINee's album was jjang. I also heard that one of the members composed the songs too, or was I wrong?

7. [+49, -12] GD was right ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ it's just the stupid fangirls who are bringing up songs that no one else knows and whining that their idols compose too ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

8. [+48, -16] GD was right though ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ SM kids always use Yoo Young Jin style SMP songs that never appeal to the public. Only fans like and listen to those songs whereas Big Bang has been producing with great results since 'Lies'. Why should GD get hate for saying the truth? EXO and SHINee fans should go take it up with Lee Soo Man and argue for those self-compositions to be title tracks and get love from the public ㅋㅋㅋ

9. [+41, -13] Even if SHINee and EXO composes their own songs... the public is only aware of like "Oh yeah, there's a member named Jonghyun who has a talent for composing and has a few songs, right?" but compare that to Big Bang and it's like....... but Big Bang composes their entire album......

-